RT.com
14 May 2022, 18:43 GMT+10
Canada's Supreme Court has axed a 1995 law that made such a defense illegal
Defendants accused of violent crimes like murder and sexual assault may use self-induced extreme intoxication - known as "non-mental disorder automatism" - as a defense in a criminal court, Canada's Supreme Court decided on Friday.
The court has ruled that a 1995 law that prohibited such a type of defense went against Canada's Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
"Its impact on the principles of fundamental justice is disproportionate to its overarching public benefits. It should therefore be declared unconstitutional and of no force or effect," Justice Nicholas Kasirer pointed out.
The law violated the Charter because the defendant's decision to become intoxicated doesn't mean that he or she was planning to commit a violent offense, Kasirer explained. It also allowed courts to convict a person without having to prove any ill intentions, he added.
The issue came before the Supreme Court last autumn and pertained to three separate cases. One of them concerned David Sullivan from Calgary, who took a prescription drug known to cause psychosis in an attempt to commit suicide back in 2013, but ended up stabbing his mother, whom he believed to be an alien at that moment due to his psychotic state.
Sullivan was barred from using the defense of extreme intoxication, and was convicted of aggravated assault and assault with a weapon. But a Court of Appeals later found the law banning such a type of defense unconstitutional and acquitted the man on both counts.
Prosecutors appealed that ruling at the Supreme Court, which confirmed Sullivan's acquittal with its decision on Friday. Canada's justice minister David Lametti said that the government was thoroughly studying the ruling.
"It is critically important to emphasize that today's decision does not apply to the vast majority of cases involving a person who commits a criminal offense while intoxicated," Lametti pointed out in a statement.
(RT.com)
Get a daily dose of Toronto Telegraph news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to Toronto Telegraph.
More InformationNEW YORK, New York - The rally in U.S. stocks petered out Tuesday, however tech stocks made a modest gains, while the industrials edged...
CALGARY, Canada: Canada's carbon pricing policy, long a central pillar of its climate strategy, is facing mounting pressure as political...
NEW BRUNSWICK, New Jersey: Johnson & Johnson is ramping up its U.S. investments even as global trade tensions resurface with plans...
WASHINGTON, D.C./DUBAI: The United Arab Emirates is significantly expanding its financial footprint in the U.S. with a new investment...
NEW YORK, New York - Investors bought up stocks on U.S. markets Monday after President Donald Trump indicated he may pull back on some...
BOSTON, Massachusetts: Private equity investor William Chisholm has agreed to buy the Boston Celtics in a record-breaking deal worth...
CALGARY, Canada: Canada's carbon pricing policy, long a central pillar of its climate strategy, is facing mounting pressure as political...
TORONTO, Canada: An initial investigation into last month's dramatic Delta Air Lines crash-landing in Toronto has revealed that the...
Washington [United States], March 26 (ANI): US President Donald Trump on Tuesday (local time) signed an executive order overhauling...
(Photo credit: Reggie Hildred-Imagn Images) The Brooklyn Nets and Toronto Raptors are separated by two games in the NBA's second-most...
(Photo credit: Dustin Safranek-Imagn Images) Something has to give Wednesday when the Washington Wizards visit the Philadelphia 76ers...
(Photo credit: Kim Klement Neitzel-Imagn Images) Two teams looking to jump back into American League contention clash in a season-opening...